Theory 1: The Outage Test
On Friday morning, as I walked through one of our elementary schools, a thought struck me: The more the Microsoft email outage hindered your workday, the more at risk your job is from AI.
That morning, our email was still down, but I watched the pre-K kids show up and sit at their desks with their little legs barely touching the floor—the same as always. The teachers greeted their students and prepared their classrooms as they would on any normal day. Other than not being distracted by their email inboxes, there was nothing different for the teachers’ in-person, essentially human-to-human jobs.
The previous night, I went to see my Detroit Pistons play the Washington Wizards. Cade Cunningham surely didn’t need his email to score 52 points in the Pistons’ win, and those of us in the crowd didn’t need much technology to make the viewing experience fun.
My job is pretty email-heavy—lots of processing and sending information—but I was still productive during the outage because the AI platforms were still working. In fact, I was probably more efficient because my thought process wasn’t constantly interrupted by email. I could finally get to some long-delayed work building tools that would save the team time.
All three experiences reinforced my theory about which jobs will be most resilient: the ones that happen in person and serve basic human needs like food, shelter, and entertainment.
And the people who will be most resilient know what their job is beyond information processing. They take agency in learning how to use new tools rather than waiting for change to happen to them.
It's also a reminder that even with change, those of us with skills and experience have the advantage if we lean in. As my friend Jeremy Utley writes in his new book, The Human Advantage, “We've been sold a myth that the future belongs to a certain type of worker who is the fastest thinker, the sharpest coder, the most fluent prompter, the young digital native, the early adopter.” Instead, he finds, “The most transformative AI work is coming from the slightly older, wiser, midcareer person who brings a true sense of their own convictions, who knows how to ask a tough question and when to triple-check the result when a proposed solution just doesn’t feel right. These are the people who know how the work gets done and demonstrate, day in and day out, why human experience is the meaningful differentiator when working with AI.”
Theory 2: Working in Offline Mode
The outage pointed to another question: How well can organizations perform in “offline mode”?
My hunch: We should expect more system interruptions in an AI world, as cyber criminals target any organization that holds money or data. Even if they don't attack our organization directly, an attack on a critical vendor can still shut us down.
The Microsoft outage wasn’t caused by a cyberattack, but it showed what a major system interruption looks like. It might be an interruption in communication systems. It might be critical organizational data locked up because of a vendor’s system breach. It might be the inability to send payments because the bank is fighting off cyberattacks.
At least in the conversations I’ve had with leaders, those risks differ from what people most imagine with AI—an employee uploading sensitive data to a chatbot. Leaders aren’t always thinking about vendor risk, or what happens when phishing scams targeting employees become so sophisticated that most people can't distinguish them from legitimate emails.
Being resilient to these interruptions means the ability to operate like we did before electronic systems were as pervasive—or in offline mode. The interesting part is that the critical organizational capabilities in offline mode are probably the skills we need in any world. For our school, it’s whether we can teach from physical books when the computers aren’t working. But that requires excellence in the same areas we'd need even with every tech tool fully operational: knowing the content deeply, understanding how students learn, and knowing how to get them excited to learn.
The future of work may look a lot like the past.
Theory 3: I Know Who Did It
The prime suspects in the Microsoft and FAA outages: The Canadians. Both have their maple syrup fingerprints all over them. No one expects the guy who's always smiling, but that's the one to investigate.
Motive: Revenge for tariffs.
(I’m 1/4th Canadian, so I can make such accusations. 😀)